
Advertiser Disclosure
SPONSORED ADVERTISING CONTENT
I Compared 5 Maca Supplements Made For Women. The Difference Was On The Back Of The Bottle
Most of them use the same handful of herbs. What they print about those herbs, and what happens when you want your money back, is where they split apart.

By Editorial Research Team
Last Updated November 19, 2026 | 5 min read
Problem
Checklist
Top 5

Why So Many Maca Supplements Leave You Guessing
Maca is everywhere right now. Drops, tablets, capsules, each one with glowing reviews and a sale timer ticking at the top of the page. So you pick one, take it every morning, and a month later you honestly can't say whether it's doing anything.
So you order another bottle. Then another. And you still can't tell a friend what's actually in it.
Truth is, most of these bottles use the same few herbs. They differ in how much they tell you about the amounts, the testing and the refund.
When I put the labels and policy pages side by side, three things separated the bottles worth paying for from the ones that only look good in an ad.
The 3 Things Every Maca Supplement Should Get Right
1.
What The Label Actually Shows You
2.
What A Month Really Costs
3.
What Happens If It Doesn't Suit You
Top 5 Maca Supplements For Women Of 2026
I lined up five maca supplements sold online to women and compared what each one prints on its label, what a month costs, what it claims about testing and what its refund policy actually says.

4.8
963+ Reviews
Pros
Amounts On The Label · 80 mg maca, 80 mg ashwagandha, 70 mg beet, 50 mg fenugreek and 4 mg L-arginine
$29.99 A Bottle · On 28-day refills, or $59.99 bought one time
No Commitment · Skip, pause or cancel up to 24 hours before a billing date
Third Party Tested · Per the brand, made in an FDA-registered, GMP-certified facility
One 2 ml Serving A Day · Under the tongue or stirred into your morning drink
Vegan And Non-GMO · No sugar added, with vegetable glycerin and water as the base
963+ Customer Reviews · Rated 4.8 out of 5 on the Amua store
Out In 1 To 2 Business Days · Most US orders arrive 4 to 8 business days after shipping
Best Value · Three bottles for $119.99 one time, or $59.99 on refills, with free shipping
Cons
50 mg herb blend with no split shown
Guarantee needs a full 90-day supply
The Verdict:
Amua came out on top for reasons you can check on the label and on the store's own policy pages.
Its label prints an amount for each of its five main ingredients and adds a 50 mg blend of five more herbs, all in one 2 ml serving of drops you take each morning.
It also says how it's made: third party tested and produced in an FDA-registered, GMP-certified facility. Only one other brand here makes claims like that, and its label hides a DHEA dose.
There is a catch: the five herbs in the blend have no individual amounts, and Novara and Vuiea print higher numbers for maca, ashwagandha and beet on a near-identical formula.
The Bottom Line:
Most of this list either hides its amounts or leans on a promise about your shape. Amua prints its amounts and says how the bottle is made and tested.
Refills ship every 28 days at $29.99, and you can skip, pause or cancel up to 24 hours before a billing date. One bottle without refills is $59.99.
Amua says it is vegan, non-GMO and third party tested, and the brand asks for 90 days of daily use before you judge it. The 90-day guarantee covers a full 90-day supply bought on shopamua.com, claimed by email within 90 days of your latest delivery. Its subscription policy says billed refill orders aren't refunded, so buy the three bottles one time if you want that cover. Individual results may vary.
Ratings and review counts are the brand's own published figures and do not necessarily reflect typical results. Please see the product website for full terms.
Learn More About Amua →
2. Liquid Maca Root by Novara Organics
by Novara Organics


4.8
1,253 Reviews
Pros
Higher Listed Amounts · 100 mg each of maca, ashwagandha and beet in 2 ml
Same Herb Lineup · Organic maca, beet and fenugreek, plus 50 mg of L-arginine
$29.99 A Bottle · On monthly delivery, or three bottles for $59.99
60 Day Refund · Money back after 60 days of use, nothing to send back
Made In The USA · No synthetic hormones or stimulants, per its FAQ
Cons
No Testing Claims · No third party, GMP, vegan or non-GMO claim on its page
Bottle Size Varies · One photo says 65 mL, another says 60 mL
Big Shape Promise · "Natural shape in 8 to 12 weeks" is its headline claim
Refill Prices Only · Its buy box shows no one-time option
The Verdict:
Novara is the closest thing to Amua on this list, and on raw numbers it prints more: 100 mg each of maca, ashwagandha and beet, 50 mg of L-arginine, plus the same kind of 50 mg blend with Tongkat Ali and ginseng. At $29.99 a bottle on monthly delivery, it costs the same too.
What held it back is everything around the formula. The page makes no testing, GMP, vegan or non-GMO claim, the bottle size changes between photos, the buy box only sells refills, and the headline sells a new shape in 8 to 12 weeks.
The Bottom Line:
If bigger numbers on the label matter most to you, Novara is a fair pick, and a refund after 60 days with nothing to post back is generous. I ranked Amua higher because it tells you more about how its bottle is made and tested.
Rankings reflect the Health Insider review of each label and policy page and do not necessarily reflect typical results from the use of these products.
3. Maca Root Drops by Vuiea
by Vuiea


4.9
1,167 Reviews
Pros
Higher Listed Amounts · 100 mg each of maca, ashwagandha and beet in 2 ml
Cheap Single Bottle · $34.99 one time, or $29.99 on monthly refills
Free US Shipping · Even on a single bottle
Vegan And Gluten Free · Both stated in its own FAQ
Cons
Strict Return Terms · Unused items only, sent back within 30 days
You Pay Return Postage · Per its refund policy, with no return address listed
No Testing Claims · No third party, GMP or non-GMO claim anywhere
Same Bottle, Many Names · Also listed as libido drops and as weight gain drops
No Company Address · Just an email address on its contact page
The Verdict:
Vuiea pours a formula that reads almost line for line like Novara's into a green-labeled bottle: 100 mg each of maca, ashwagandha and beet, 50 mg each of L-arginine and fenugreek, and a 50 mg blend. You can also buy one bottle without refills for $34.99, with free US shipping.
The catch is the paperwork behind it. The refund policy only takes back unused items within 30 days, at your cost, the store gives no business name or address, and the same bottle is sold under other names.
The Bottom Line:
A solid label at a fair price, and the free shipping helps. Thin company details and a strict return policy are why it sits at three.
Rankings reflect the Health Insider review of each label and policy page and do not necessarily reflect typical results from the use of these products.
4. Peach Power by PeachyMe
by PeachyMe


4.5
391 Trustpilot Reviews
Pros
Vitamins With Amounts · Vitamin D, E and B6 plus 8 billion CFU of probiotics
Third Party Tested · Per the brand, plus heavy metal tested and GMP certified
Free US Shipping · $29.99 a bottle on refills every 28 days
Cons
Contains DHEA · A hormone precursor, inside a blend with no amount
Says Hormone Free · Its FAQ says so, while its own label lists DHEA
Every Herb In A Blend · Black cohosh, dong quai, maca and more, with no split
Three Capsules A Day · 90 capsules for a 30-day supply
14-Day Window · The shortest stated guarantee on this list
Unopened Returns Only · Its terms also make you pay the return postage
Cancel Fee In The Terms · Cancel before the first refill and you pay the difference
The Verdict:
PeachyMe takes a different route from the drops on this list: three capsules a day holding vitamins, a probiotic and four herbal blends, sold as a curve formula with free US shipping and testing claims in its photos and FAQ. The problem is what sits inside those blends. The label lists DHEA, a hormone precursor, with no amount, while the FAQ calls the product hormone-free.
The Bottom Line:
The vitamins and probiotic are clearly dosed, which counts for something. But a hidden DHEA dose and a 14-day guarantee that wants the bottle unopened put it at four. If you take anything hormone-related, ask your doctor before you start.
Assessment is based on the brand's published label and policy pages, and does not reflect independent lab testing of the bottle itself.
5. Appetite And Mass Enhancer by Rosamin
by Rosamin


N/A
No Reviews Posted
Pros
Maca In Both Bottles · Black maca and maca root, plus aguaje and primrose
Two Formulas, One Pack · A mass formula and a second formula, 28 tablets each
No Measuring · One tablet from each bottle, twice a day
Cons
No amount for any single ingredient
No Supplement Facts panel shown
Priciest Per Day · €65 a pack, and four tablets a day empties it in 14 days
Priced in euros, shipping extra
No Reviews Or Refund Terms · Nothing posted on the store, and no return policy
The Verdict:
Rosamin is the only tablet on this list, and its one listing is pitched at appetite and body mass, with maca in both of its two bottles.
The Bottom Line:
All you get is ingredient names and a single 660 mg figure. No breakdown, no facts panel, no reviews and no return terms. At €65 for roughly two weeks of tablets, it is hard to judge and easy to overpay for, which is why it sits at five.
Rankings reflect the Health Insider review of each label and policy page and do not necessarily reflect typical results from the use of these products.
The Clear Winner: Amua VitalDrops
After lining up all five, one came out ahead on the things you can actually check:
Printed amounts for its five main ingredients
Third party tested, per the brand
Made in an FDA-registered, GMP-certified facility
Vegan, non-GMO, no sugar added
$29.99 a bottle on 28-day refills
Skip, pause or cancel before each billing date
90-day guarantee on a full 90-day supply
That brand is Amua.
Why Amua Is Different
Most maca bottles give you a list of herb names and a promise
Amua prints the amounts for its five main ingredients and says the bottle is third party tested.
On price, it lands where most of this list does: $29.99 a bottle on refills or $59.99 without, plus a 90-day guarantee on a full 90-day supply bought on its own site.
Learn More About Amua →
The Bottom Line
If you're going to take a maca supplement every day, take one that tells you what's in it.
Five printed amounts. One 2 ml serving. $29.99 a bottle on refills.
Anything vaguer leaves you paying for a guess.
See Today's Amua Offer →

© 2026 Health Insider. All rights reserved.
Trademarks used on this website belong to their respective owners, and no implied or expressed endorsement of our website or services is intended. Rankings can be affected by the relationship we have with our top picks.
[1] The owner of this website has a material, compensated connection to Amua.
* The information on this site is not intended as a substitute for professional medical advice. If you have or suspect you may have any medical condition, are pregnant, nursing or taking medication, consult a health care provider before use. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Rankings are based on our Ranking System and do not necessarily reflect typical results from the use of these products. Individual results may vary.
© 2026 AMUA | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Contact Us | Refund Policy | Shipping Policy
#1 AMUA VitalDrops
